
The USDA on Friday OK'd snowmaking at Arizona Snowbowl, using either reclaimed wastewater or tapping directly into Flagstaff's potable water lines. (Josh Biggs/Arizona Daily Sun, file)
Tribes who oppose construction at Arizona Snowbowl, because wastewater is used in snowmaking on their sacred sites, have asked a judge to stop construction there, the Arizona Daily Sun in Flagstaff reports here:
Attorney Howard Shanker filed a request for a temporary restraining order on Tuesday with Judge Mary Murguia, in the U.S. District Court for Arizona.
The action comes after Friday’s decision by the U.S. Department of Agriculture to allow snowmaking and related construction on the (San Francisco) Peaks, an approval that becomes effective next week.
Shanker’s tribal clients failed to prevail in court in arguing that making snow with reclaimed wastewater on the sacred San Francisco Peaks violated their religious freedom.
A court hearing is scheduled for next week on the issue. Meanwhile, the Daily Sun writes that Snowbowl owner Eric Borowsky has said he will ask the Flagstaff City Council for potable water.
That would necessitate approval of a new contract from the council, which has already approved the sale of reclaimed wastewater to Snowbowl. Potable water is, of course, more expensive than wastewater.
Thirteen tribes consider the mountains sacred. Only the Navajo Nation has said the potable water would be preferable.
The Daily Sun lists the following as claimants: Save the Peaks Coalition and Kristin Huisinga, Clayson Benally, Sylvan Grey, Don Fanning, Jeneda Benally, Frederica Hall, Berta Benally, Rachel Tso and Lisa Tso.
A Daily Sun editorial, here, counsels restraint – and communication:
-
We’d urge Snowbowl to hold off before cutting any trees up on the mountain. There appear to be a lot of loose ends to tie up, and we’d hate to see something done today that we all might want to see undone tomorrow.
Our recommendation remains to get all parties to the same table to talk it out, not negotiate separately, as the Forest Service and now the USDA appear to have done.
Gwen Florio
Tags: buffalo post, Gwen Florio, Judge Mary Murguia, Native American news, Navajo Nation, San Francisco Peaks, Snowbowl, U.S. Department of Agriculture, U.S. District Court

